Tutorial: Query Classifier

_{Last Updated:
December 22, 2022}

One of the great benefits of using state-of-the-art NLP models like those available in Haystack is that it allows users to state their queries as plain natural language questions: rather than trying to come up with just the right set of keywords to find the answer to their question, users can simply ask their question in much the same way that they would ask it of a (very knowledgeable!) person.

But just because users can ask their questions in “plain English” (or “plain German”, etc.), that doesn’t mean they always will. For instance, a user might input a few keywords rather than a complete question because they don’t understand the pipeline’s full capabilities, or because they are so accustomed to keyword search. While a standard Haystack pipeline might handle such queries with reasonable accuracy, for a variety of reasons we still might prefer that our pipeline be sensitive to the type of query it is receiving, so that it behaves differently when a user inputs, say, a collection of keywords instead of a question.

For this reason, Haystack comes with built-in capabilities to distinguish between three types of queries: keyword queries, interrogative queries, and statement queries, described below.

Keyword queries can be thought of more or less as lists of words, such as “Alaska cruises summer”. While the meanings of individual words may matter in a keyword query, the linguistic connections between words do not. Hence, in a keyword query the order of words is largely irrelevant: “Alaska cruises summer”, “summer Alaska cruises”, and “summer cruises Alaska” are functionally the same.
Interrogative queries (or question queries) are queries phrased as natural language questions, such as “Who was the father of Eddard Stark?”. Unlike with keyword queries, word order very much matters here: “Who was the father of Eddard Stark?” and “Who was Eddard Stark the father of?” are very different questions, despite having exactly the same words. (Note that while we often write questions with question marks, Haystack can find interrogative queries without such a dead giveaway!)
Statement queries are just declarative sentences, such as “Daenerys loved Jon”. These are like interrogative queries in that word order matters—again, “Daenerys loved Jon” and “Jon loved Daenerys” mean very different things—but they are statements instead of questions.

In this tutorial you will learn how to use query classifiers to branch your Haystack pipeline based on the type of query it receives. Haystack comes with two out-of-the-box query classification schemas, each of which routes a given query into one of two branches:

Keyword vs. Question/Statement — routes a query into one of two branches depending on whether it is a full question/statement or a collection of keywords.
Question vs. Statement — routes a natural language query into one of two branches depending on whether it is a question or a statement.

Furthermore, for each classification schema there are two types of nodes capable of performing this classification: a TransformersQueryClassifier that uses a transformer model, and an SklearnQueryClassifier that uses a more lightweight model built in sklearn.

With all of that explanation out of the way, let’s dive in!

Prepare the Environment

Colab: Enable the GPU runtime

Make sure you enable the GPU runtime to experience decent speed in this tutorial.
Runtime -> Change Runtime type -> Hardware accelerator -> GPU

You can double check whether the GPU runtime is enabled with the following command:

%%bash

nvidia-smi

Next we make sure the latest version of Haystack is installed:

%%bash

pip install --upgrade pip
pip install git+https://github.com/deepset-ai/haystack.git#egg=farm-haystack[colab]

# Install these to allow pipeline visualization
apt install libgraphviz-dev
pip install pygraphviz

Logging

We configure how logging messages should be displayed and which log level should be used before importing Haystack. Example log message: INFO - haystack.utils.preprocessing - Converting data/tutorial1/218_Olenna_Tyrell.txt Default log level in basicConfig is WARNING so the explicit parameter is not necessary but can be changed easily:

import logging

logging.basicConfig(format="%(levelname)s - %(name)s -  %(message)s", level=logging.WARNING)
logging.getLogger("haystack").setLevel(logging.INFO)

Trying Some Query Classifiers on their Own

Before integrating query classifiers into our pipelines, let’s test them out on their own and see what they actually do. First we initiate a simple, out-of-the-box keyword vs. question/statement SklearnQueryClassifier:

# Here we create the keyword vs question/statement query classifier
from haystack.nodes import SklearnQueryClassifier

keyword_classifier = SklearnQueryClassifier()

Now let’s feed some queries into this query classifier. We’ll test with one keyword query, one interrogative query, and one statement query. Note that we don’t need to use any punctuation, such as question marks, for the query classifier to make the right decision.

queries = [
    "Arya Stark father",  # Keyword Query
    "Who was the father of Arya Stark",  # Interrogative Query
    "Lord Eddard was the father of Arya Stark",  # Statement Query
]

Below, you can see what the classifier does with these queries: it correctly determines that “Arya Stark father” is a keyword query and sends it to branch 2. It also correctly classifies both the interrogative query “Who was the father of Arya Stark” and the statement query “Lord Eddard was the father of Arya Stark” as non-keyword queries, and sends them to branch 1.

import pandas as pd

k_vs_qs_results = {"Query": [], "Output Branch": [], "Class": []}

for query in queries:
    result = keyword_classifier.run(query=query)
    k_vs_qs_results["Query"].append(query)
    k_vs_qs_results["Output Branch"].append(result[1])
    k_vs_qs_results["Class"].append("Question/Statement" if result[1] == "output_1" else "Keyword")

pd.DataFrame.from_dict(k_vs_qs_results)

Next, we will illustrate a question vs. statement SklearnQueryClassifier. We define our classifier below. Note that this time we have to explicitly specify the model and vectorizer since the default for a SklearnQueryClassifier (and a TransformersQueryClassifier) is keyword vs. question/statement classification.

# Here we create the question vs statement query classifier
model_url = (
    "https://ext-models-haystack.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/gradboost_query_classifier_statements/model.pickle"
)
vectorizer_url = (
    "https://ext-models-haystack.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/gradboost_query_classifier_statements/vectorizer.pickle"
)

question_classifier = SklearnQueryClassifier(model_name_or_path=model_url, vectorizer_name_or_path=vectorizer_url)

We will test this classifier on the two question/statement queries from the last go-round:

queries = [
    "Who was the father of Arya Stark",  # Interrogative Query
    "Lord Eddard was the father of Arya Stark",  # Statement Query
]

q_vs_s_results = {"Query": [], "Output Branch": [], "Class": []}

for query in queries:
    result = question_classifier.run(query=query)
    q_vs_s_results["Query"].append(query)
    q_vs_s_results["Output Branch"].append(result[1])
    q_vs_s_results["Class"].append("Question" if result[1] == "output_1" else "Statement")

pd.DataFrame.from_dict(q_vs_s_results)

And as we see, the question “Who was the father of Arya Stark” is sent to branch 1, while the statement “Lord Eddard was the father of Arya Stark” is sent to branch 2. This means we can have our pipeline treat statements and questions differently.

Using Query Classifiers in a Pipeline

Now let’s see how we can use query classifiers in a question-answering (QA) pipeline. We start by initiating Elasticsearch:

Start an Elasticsearch server

You can start Elasticsearch on your local machine instance using Docker. If Docker is not readily available in your environment (eg., in Colab notebooks), then you can manually download and execute Elasticsearch from source.

# Recommended: Start Elasticsearch using Docker via the Haystack utility function
from haystack.utils import launch_es

launch_es()

Start an Elasticsearch server in Colab

If Docker is not readily available in your environment (e.g. in Colab notebooks), then you can manually download and execute Elasticsearch from source.

%%bash

wget https://artifacts.elastic.co/downloads/elasticsearch/elasticsearch-7.9.2-linux-x86_64.tar.gz -q
tar -xzf elasticsearch-7.9.2-linux-x86_64.tar.gz
chown -R daemon:daemon elasticsearch-7.9.2

%%bash --bg

sudo -u daemon -- elasticsearch-7.9.2/bin/elasticsearch

Next we fetch some data—for our example we’ll use pages from the Game of Thrones wiki—and index it in our DocumentStore:

from haystack.utils import fetch_archive_from_http, convert_files_to_docs, clean_wiki_text

# Download and prepare data - 517 Wikipedia articles for Game of Thrones
doc_dir = "data/tutorial14"
s3_url = "https://s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/deepset.ai-farm-qa/datasets/documents/wiki_gameofthrones_txt14.zip"
fetch_archive_from_http(url=s3_url, output_dir=doc_dir)

# convert files to dicts containing documents that can be indexed to our datastore
got_docs = convert_files_to_docs(dir_path=doc_dir, clean_func=clean_wiki_text, split_paragraphs=True)

import os
import time

from haystack.document_stores import ElasticsearchDocumentStore


# Wait 30 seconds only to be sure Elasticsearch is ready before continuing
time.sleep(30)

# Get the host where Elasticsearch is running, default to localhost
host = os.environ.get("ELASTICSEARCH_HOST", "localhost")


document_store = ElasticsearchDocumentStore()
document_store.delete_documents()
document_store.write_documents(got_docs)

Pipelines with Keyword vs. Question/Statement Classification

Our first illustration will be a simple retriever-reader QA pipeline, but the choice of which retriever we use will depend on the type of query received: keyword queries will use a sparse BM25Retriever, while question/statement queries will use the more accurate but also more computationally expensive EmbeddingRetriever.

We start by initializing our retrievers and reader:

from haystack.nodes import BM25Retriever, EmbeddingRetriever, FARMReader


# Initialize sparse retriever for keyword queries
bm25_retriever = BM25Retriever(document_store=document_store)

# Initialize dense retriever for question/statement queries
embedding_retriever = EmbeddingRetriever(
    document_store=document_store, embedding_model="sentence-transformers/multi-qa-mpnet-base-dot-v1"
)
document_store.update_embeddings(embedding_retriever, update_existing_embeddings=False)

reader = FARMReader(model_name_or_path="deepset/roberta-base-squad2")

Now we define our pipeline. As promised, the question/statement branch output_1 from the query classifier is fed into an EmbeddingRetriever, while the keyword branch output_2 from the same classifier is fed into a BM25Retriever. Both of these retrievers are then fed into our reader. Our pipeline can thus be thought of as having something of a diamond shape: all queries are sent into the classifier, which splits those queries into two different retrievers, and those retrievers feed their outputs to the same reader.

from haystack.pipelines import Pipeline


# Here we build the pipeline
sklearn_keyword_classifier = Pipeline()
sklearn_keyword_classifier.add_node(component=SklearnQueryClassifier(), name="QueryClassifier", inputs=["Query"])
sklearn_keyword_classifier.add_node(
    component=embedding_retriever, name="EmbeddingRetriever", inputs=["QueryClassifier.output_1"]
)
sklearn_keyword_classifier.add_node(component=bm25_retriever, name="BM25Retriever", inputs=["QueryClassifier.output_2"])
sklearn_keyword_classifier.add_node(component=reader, name="QAReader", inputs=["BM25Retriever", "EmbeddingRetriever"])

# To generate a visualization of the pipeline, uncomment the following:
# sklearn_keyword_classifier.draw("sklearn_keyword_classifier.png")

Below, we can see how this choice affects the branching structure: the keyword query “arya stark father” and the question query “Who is the father of Arya Stark?” generate noticeably different results, a distinction that is likely due to the use of different retrievers for keyword vs. question/statement queries.

from haystack.utils import print_answers


# Useful for framing headers
equal_line = "=" * 30

# Run only the dense retriever on the full sentence query
res_1 = sklearn_keyword_classifier.run(query="Who is the father of Arya Stark?")
print(f"\n\n{equal_line}\nQUESTION QUERY RESULTS\n{equal_line}")
print_answers(res_1, details="minimum")
print("\n\n")

# Run only the sparse retriever on a keyword based query
res_2 = sklearn_keyword_classifier.run(query="arya stark father")
print(f"\n\n{equal_line}\nKEYWORD QUERY RESULTS\n{equal_line}")
print_answers(res_2, details="minimum")

The above example uses an SklearnQueryClassifier, but of course we can do precisely the same thing with a TransformersQueryClassifier. This is illustrated below, where we have constructed the same diamond-shaped pipeline.

from haystack.nodes import TransformersQueryClassifier

# Here we build the pipeline
transformer_keyword_classifier = Pipeline()
transformer_keyword_classifier.add_node(
    component=TransformersQueryClassifier(), name="QueryClassifier", inputs=["Query"]
)
transformer_keyword_classifier.add_node(
    component=embedding_retriever, name="EmbeddingRetriever", inputs=["QueryClassifier.output_1"]
)
transformer_keyword_classifier.add_node(
    component=bm25_retriever, name="BM25Retriever", inputs=["QueryClassifier.output_2"]
)
transformer_keyword_classifier.add_node(
    component=reader, name="QAReader", inputs=["BM25Retriever", "EmbeddingRetriever"]
)


# Useful for framing headers
equal_line = "=" * 30

# Run only the dense retriever on the full sentence query
res_1 = transformer_keyword_classifier.run(query="Who is the father of Arya Stark?")
print(f"\n\n{equal_line}\nQUESTION QUERY RESULTS\n{equal_line}")
print_answers(res_1, details="minimum")
print("\n\n")

# Run only the sparse retriever on a keyword based query
res_2 = transformer_keyword_classifier.run(query="arya stark father")
print(f"\n\n{equal_line}\nKEYWORD QUERY RESULTS\n{equal_line}")
print_answers(res_2, details="minimum")

Pipeline with Question vs. Statement Classification

Above we saw a potential use for keyword vs. question/statement classification: we might choose to use a less resource-intensive retriever for keyword queries than for question/statement queries. But what about question vs. statement classification?

To illustrate one potential use for question vs. statement classification, we will build a pipeline that looks as follows:

The pipeline will start with a retriever that every query will go through.
The pipeline will end with a reader that only question queries will go through.

In other words, our pipeline will be a retriever-only pipeline for statement queries—given the statement “Arya Stark was the daughter of a Lord”, all we will get back are the most relevant documents—but it will be a retriever-reader pipeline for question queries.

To make things more concrete, our pipeline will start with a retriever, which is then fed into a TransformersQueryClassifier that is set to do question vs. statement classification. Note that this means we need to explicitly choose the model, since as mentioned previously a default TransformersQueryClassifier performs keyword vs. question/statement classification. The classifier’s first branch, which handles question queries, will then be sent to the reader, while the second branch will not be connected to any other nodes. As a result, the last node of the pipeline depends on the type of query: questions go all the way through the reader, while statements only go through the retriever. This pipeline is illustrated below:

# Here we build the pipeline
transformer_question_classifier = Pipeline()
transformer_question_classifier.add_node(component=embedding_retriever, name="EmbeddingRetriever", inputs=["Query"])
transformer_question_classifier.add_node(
    component=TransformersQueryClassifier(model_name_or_path="shahrukhx01/question-vs-statement-classifier"),
    name="QueryClassifier",
    inputs=["EmbeddingRetriever"],
)
transformer_question_classifier.add_node(component=reader, name="QAReader", inputs=["QueryClassifier.output_1"])

# To generate a visualization of the pipeline, uncomment the following:
# transformer_question_classifier.draw("transformer_question_classifier.png")

And here are the results of this pipeline: with a question query like “Who is the father of Arya Stark?”, we obtain answers from a reader, and with a statement query like “Arya Stark was the daughter of a Lord”, we just obtain documents from a retriever.

from haystack.utils import print_documents


# Useful for framing headers
equal_line = "=" * 30

# Run the retriever + reader on the question query
res_1 = transformer_question_classifier.run(query="Who is the father of Arya Stark?")
print(f"\n\n{equal_line}\nQUESTION QUERY RESULTS\n{equal_line}")
print_answers(res_1, details="minimum")
print("\n\n")

# Run only the retriever on the statement query
res_2 = transformer_question_classifier.run(query="Arya Stark was the daughter of a Lord.")
print(f"\n\n{equal_line}\nSTATEMENT QUERY RESULTS\n{equal_line}")
print_documents(res_2)

Other use cases for Query Classifiers: custom classification models and zero-shot classification.

TransformersQueryClassifier is very flexible and also supports other options for classifying queries. For example, we may be interested in detecting the sentiment or classifying the topics. We can do this by loading a custom classification model from the Hugging Face Hub or by using zero-shot classification.

Custom classification model vs zero-shot classification

Rraditional text classification models are trained to predict one of a few “hard-coded” classes and require a dedicated training dataset. In the Hugging Face Hub, you can find many pre-trained models, maybe even related to your domain of interest.
Zero-shot classification is very versatile: by choosing a suitable base transformer, you can classify the text without any training dataset. You just have to provide the candidate categories.

Using custom classification models

We can use a public model, available in the Hugging Face Hub. For example, if we want to classify the sentiment of the queries, we can choose an appropriate model, such as https://huggingface.co/cardiffnlp/twitter-roberta-base-sentiment.

In this case, the labels parameter must contain a list with the exact model labels. The first label we provide corresponds to output_1, the second label to output_2, and so on.

# Remember to compile a list with the exact model labels
# The first label you provide corresponds to output_1, the second label to output_2, and so on.
labels = ["LABEL_0", "LABEL_1", "LABEL_2"]

sentiment_query_classifier = TransformersQueryClassifier(
    model_name_or_path="cardiffnlp/twitter-roberta-base-sentiment",
    use_gpu=True,
    task="text-classification",
    labels=labels,
)

queries = [
    "What's the answer?",  # neutral query
    "Would you be so lovely to tell me the answer?",  # positive query
    "Can you give me the damn right answer for once??",  # negative query
]

import pandas as pd

sent_results = {"Query": [], "Output Branch": [], "Class": []}

for query in queries:
    result = sentiment_query_classifier.run(query=query)
    sent_results["Query"].append(query)
    sent_results["Output Branch"].append(result[1])
    if result[1] == "output_1":
        sent_results["Class"].append("negative")
    elif result[1] == "output_2":
        sent_results["Class"].append("neutral")
    elif result[1] == "output_3":
        sent_results["Class"].append("positive")

pd.DataFrame.from_dict(sent_results)

Using zero-shot classification

You can also perform zero-shot classification by providing a suitable base transformer model and choosing the classes the model should predict. For example, we may be interested in whether the user query is related to music or cinema.

In this case, the labels parameter is a list containing the candidate classes.

# In zero-shot-classification, you can choose the labels
labels = ["music", "cinema"]

query_classifier = TransformersQueryClassifier(
    model_name_or_path="typeform/distilbert-base-uncased-mnli",
    use_gpu=True,
    task="zero-shot-classification",
    labels=labels,
)

queries = [
    "In which films does John Travolta appear?",  # query about cinema
    "What is the Rolling Stones first album?",  # query about music
    "Who was Sergio Leone?",  # query about cinema
]

import pandas as pd

query_classification_results = {"Query": [], "Output Branch": [], "Class": []}

for query in queries:
    result = query_classifier.run(query=query)
    query_classification_results["Query"].append(query)
    query_classification_results["Output Branch"].append(result[1])
    query_classification_results["Class"].append("music" if result[1] == "output_1" else "cinema")

pd.DataFrame.from_dict(query_classification_results)

About us

This Haystack notebook was made with love by deepset in Berlin, Germany

We bring NLP to the industry via open source!
Our focus: Industry specific language models & large scale QA systems.

Some of our other work:

Get in touch: Twitter | LinkedIn | Discord | GitHub Discussions | Website

By the way: we’re hiring!

Question Generation

Document Classification at Index Time